Of LEGOS and Creativity

Jackie Drummer • February 1, 2025

Have you ever looked at LEGOS and wondered about how they best stimulate creativity? Which LEGO activities – pre-made kits, complete with step-by-step directions – or free play with LEGOS in a “create your own adventure” scenario – contribute most to creativity in children and adults? And how does this translate into everyday activities? And what are the implications for businesses/the workforce? 


Apparently, the people at LEGO have wondered about these questions, and have done some very interesting research. In this article, The Downstream Consequences of Problem-Solving Mindsets: How Playing with LEGO Influences Creativity, researchers pondered the effect of open-ended vs. closed-ended tasks using LEGOS. Their study has theoretical implications for creativity and mindset research as well as insights for managers and public policy makers. 


According to the researchers, “Recent trends in technology and education suggest that the opportunities to engage in exploratory thinking may be declining for a number of people. Google provides immediate answers, teachers ‘teach to the test,’ and overscheduled lives leave fewer opportunities to discover or pursue new interests. Essentially, many of the problems we face on a daily basis are becoming increasingly more structured and well defined.”


A perfect example of this highly structured and well-defined outcome is the plethora of LEGO “kits”, with precise directions and precise outcomes. Apparently, consumers are increasingly preferring this…“the double-digit growth in LEGO’s revenues indicates that consumers have a strong desire to solve these types of well-structured problems”. (Hansegard and Burkitt 2013).


But at what price?


To research this, LEGO created several experiments. They were interested in understanding how adult consumers reacted to their products. Each randomly assigned participant was given a 40-piece LEGO set and fifteen minutes of work time. Half of the participants were given precise directions and a desired outcome; the other half were asked to “build something”. Then both groups proceeded to a second task, either the Torrance Test of Creative Thinking or the Miller Analogy Task. (Note that a control group proceeded to one of the second tasks without doing the LEGO task. Note also that all participants took two pretests to examine whether factors – such as perceiving that one innately “excels at creativity” could influence performance on the subsequent task).


So, what did the researchers find out? 


Essentially, those who were given the open-ended task of “building something” out of LEGOS outperformed those who were given specific directions when they engaged in future creative tests. Apparently, being creative encouraged/strengthened further creativity. The study also confirmed that the effects were not driven by a person's motivation to be creative; instead the effects were driven by a reduction in the extent of divergent thinking in which the person engages. Creativity, then, like any other “muscle”, needs to be flexed in order to strengthen. The more we explore on our own – without explicit direction – the greater the chances that creativity will flourish.


So, what are the implications for education and the workforce? 


The researchers used Disney as a concrete example: “Disney distinguishes between employees who do ‘routine work’ (e.g., cast members at their theme parks) and those who engage in imaginative work (e.g., ‘imagineers’ who ‘dream up wild ideas about new things a guest might experience’; Sutton 2001). Routine work entails well-defined-problem solving, whereas imaginative work requires engagement in ill-defined-problem solving. Employees rarely switch from one type of work to the other, and our findings suggest that this separation is a good one…employees consistently engaged in routine work would produce less-creative ideas than those who were not so engaged.”


My question then is this: which is more important – more engagement with creative experiences to strengthen the creative disposition and provide a workout for the creativity “muscle” – or allow our ever-increasing reliance on gadgets, directions, and AI to govern our future? What do you think?


As always, I welcome your ideas. Together we grow.


Jackie Drummer, Past President and WATG Board Advisor


Thank you to Esther Vasquez for her translation of this article for our Spanish speaking families and educators.

The 2025 WATG Conference invites educators and families to explore innovative, inclusive practices t
By Maria Katsaros-Molzahn July 25, 2025
The 2025 WATG Conference invites educators and families to explore innovative, inclusive practices that help all gifted learners and communities thrive.
By Jackie Drummer July 25, 2025
Jackie Drummer highlights how critical thinking boosts academic success and shares real-world strategies to build key skills in upper elementary students.
By Jennifer Neuman July 12, 2025
This blog explores using the SCAMPER framework to help gifted middle schoolers reimagine stories, boost creativity, and strengthen writing through ELA lessons.
By Michelle Burch July 12, 2025
Michelle Burch highlights how early transparency, collaboration, and clear communication among coordinators, teachers, and families support gifted learners’ success.
July 12, 2025
Vincent Balzrina shares how his middle school's GT program provided enriching opportunities that helped him grow as a student and person.
A man with a beard is wearing a blue shirt and tie.
By German Diaz June 27, 2025
The 2022–2023 State of the States Report highlights disparities in gifted education and serves as a vital advocacy tool for promoting equity and support nationwide.
By Jackie Drummer June 26, 2025
Explore evolving parenting styles—from authoritarian to "lighthouse"—and learn how supportive guidance fosters confident, resilient, and independent kids.
A woman wearing glasses and a scarf smiles for the camera
By Maria Katsaros-Molzahn June 18, 2025
WATG, in partnership with the Department of Public Instruction, hosted a series of in-person and virtual sessions through the Four Corners Grant to support student talent development across Wisconsin. Educators played a vital role in promoting participation, and collaborative efforts like the Jane Goodall “Roots and Shoots” project provided meaningful, real-world leadership experiences for students. WATG continues to offer enriching opportunities, including its upcoming fall conference.
A man is playing a game of chess on a glass table
By Mary Pape June 18, 2025
This blog post explores the tension between creativity and imitation in an age dominated by social media and AI. It warns that constant exposure to repetitive content and over reliance on tools like ChatGPT can diminish original thinking, even for gifted individuals. True creativity thrives on unique perspectives, and we must be mindful to preserve and nurture our own creative abilities.
A woman with long brown hair is smiling in front of a marble wall.
By Laura Mukerji June 15, 2025
This post explores the power of student choice as a strategy for differentiation in the classroom, especially for gifted learners. It highlights how giving students voice in their content, process, product, and pacing enhances motivation, creativity, and deeper engagement. The article introduces the Student Choice Board, a flexible tool structured into three tiers – “Try It,” “Stretch It,” and “Make It Yours” – to guide student autonomy while aligning with core learning goals. Practical classroom examples across subject areas demonstrate how choice fosters ownership and meaningful learning. A customizable Canva template is also provided.
Show More