Challenging the Myth that "All Students are Gifted"

Laura Mukerji • February 15, 2025

One common misconception I have encountered several times as an educator and parent is the idea that “all students are gifted”. While this notion is undoubtedly well-intentioned, and it is true that every child possesses unique talents and strengths, equating these traits with giftedness in an educational context undermines the needs of students who require specialized support in the field of gifted and talented education. This misbelief dilutes the resources and services essential for these students to thrive and perpetuates inequalities both in the classroom and beyond.


To understand why this is problematic, it’s important to clarify what giftedness truly means. Giftedness is more than simply being a bright or high-achieving student. According to Rimm, Davis, and Siegle in Education of the Gifted and Talented, “There is no one definition of gifted, talented, or giftedness that is universally accepted. Common usage of the terms even by experts is ambiguous and inconsistent” (2017). In Wisconsin, “Gifted and talented pupils” means pupils enrolled in public schools who give evidence of high performance capability in intellectual, creative, artistic, leadership, or specific academic areas and who need services or activities not ordinarily provided in a regular school program in order to fully develop such capabilities (Wis. Stat. § 118.35, 2025). Gifted individuals may also exhibit traits such as heightened observation, curiosity, and alertness. These areas set gifted students apart from their peers and highlight a need for targeted support from educators. 


In addition to these areas, gifted students often face unique challenges and have special social and emotional needs. They may struggle with feelings of isolation when their abilities set them apart from peers, making it difficult to form meaningful friendships. Others might experience intense perfectionism, fearing failure so deeply that they avoid challenges altogether. Some gifted students have heightened sensitivity to criticism or injustice, which can make daily interactions with peers and teachers emotionally overwhelming and exhausting. Additionally, some students are twice-exceptional, meaning they are gifted while also having a learning difference. These students may require both enrichment opportunities and accommodations to address their areas of struggle, creating a unique set of needs that requires careful, individualized support. Addressing these challenges requires a collaborative effort from educators, parents, and mental health professionals to create a supportive environment that encourages resilience, a growth mindset, self-acceptance, and healthy coping strategies.


Stating that “all children are gifted” not only diminishes the unique strengths of gifted students but also downplays their social and emotional struggles. This misconception can lead to significant consequences for gifted learners. Gifted students who are not adequately challenged often experience boredom, frustration, and underachievement. (National Association for Gifted Children, n.d.) Research has shown that when the needs of gifted teens are ignored, they are at a higher risk for issues such as depression, disengagement, a higher dropout rate, and receive poorer grades, which in turn perpetuates the problem. Proper identification and recognition of the unique needs of these students are the first step to helping these students thrive instead of merely enduring


It is worth acknowledging that the phrase “all students are gifted” usually comes from a few well-meaning place; the person using the phrase is promoting inclusivity and celebrating the strengths of all learners. While the desire for inclusivity is wonderful, it is important to use the language of giftedness as defined in an educational context. It is important to recognize that some students require special programs or services to reach their full potential. This need does not detract from the value of other students, rather, it ensures equity by providing all students with the resources they need to succeed. 


So what can be done? Educators can address this issue by implementing differentiated instruction, multiple tiers of instruction, and project-based learning where students are allowed the opportunity for challenge and enrichment. Schools can prioritize professional development for teachers to help them identify and support gifted students academically and emotionally. As a family of educators, we can recognize the potential in every student and work to support all students across their educational career – helping to meet their developmental needs. Finally, we can recognize the social, emotional, and academic needs of gifted learners as needs requiring support in the education system.


While every child is indeed special, not every child is gifted in the educational sense. For educators and other school professionals, it is crucial to recognize this distinction in order to provide meaningful challenges, resources, and appropriate support to foster the potential of all students. As educators and advocates, we must move beyond the idea that “all students are gifted” as a narrative and instead focus on creating inclusive environments that respect and nurture the unique needs of all learners, including gifted learners.



References:

National Association for Gifted Children. (n.d.). Myths about gifted students. Retrieved January 27, 2025, from https://nagc.org/page/myths-about-gifted-students


Rimm, S. B., Siegle, D., & Davis, G. A. (2018). Education of the gifted and talented (7th ed.). Pearson.


Wisconsin Statutes § 118.35. (2025). Gifted and talented pupils. https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/statutes/statutes/118/35



By Laura Mukerji, WATG Board Member

A woman wearing glasses and a scarf smiles for the camera
By Maria Katsaros-Molzahn June 18, 2025
WATG, in partnership with the Department of Public Instruction, hosted a series of in-person and virtual sessions through the Four Corners Grant to support student talent development across Wisconsin. Educators played a vital role in promoting participation, and collaborative efforts like the Jane Goodall “Roots and Shoots” project provided meaningful, real-world leadership experiences for students. WATG continues to offer enriching opportunities, including its upcoming fall conference.
A man is playing a game of chess on a glass table
By Mary Pape June 18, 2025
This blog post explores the tension between creativity and imitation in an age dominated by social media and AI. It warns that constant exposure to repetitive content and over reliance on tools like ChatGPT can diminish original thinking, even for gifted individuals. True creativity thrives on unique perspectives, and we must be mindful to preserve and nurture our own creative abilities.
A woman with long brown hair is smiling in front of a marble wall.
By Laura Mukerji June 15, 2025
This post explores the power of student choice as a strategy for differentiation in the classroom, especially for gifted learners. It highlights how giving students voice in their content, process, product, and pacing enhances motivation, creativity, and deeper engagement. The article introduces the Student Choice Board, a flexible tool structured into three tiers – “Try It,” “Stretch It,” and “Make It Yours” – to guide student autonomy while aligning with core learning goals. Practical classroom examples across subject areas demonstrate how choice fosters ownership and meaningful learning. A customizable Canva template is also provided.
A woman wearing glasses and a necklace is smiling for the camera.
By Lalitha Murali May 31, 2025
This blog post reflects on a powerful leadership workshop experience through Jane Goodall's Roots & Shoots Program, hosted by WATG and the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction. Over 60 students from Glen Hills Middle School participated in activities focused on self-reflection, empathy, and community leadership. Highlights included the "Tree of Hope" activity, where students explored their passions, goals, and personal identities through creative expression. Testimonials from 4th and 8th graders emphasize the emotional and personal impact of the workshop. The event concluded with a Glen Hills Cleanup activity, reinforcing the importance of taking meaningful action.
A woman is smiling in front of a wall of paintings.
By Stacy Novak May 15, 2025
This insightful post by Nikki Radcliffe explores the often-overlooked emotional challenges faced by gifted learners, including perfectionism, asynchronous development, and social isolation. While gifted students may excel academically, they can struggle with stress, anxiety, and emotional regulation if their social-emotional needs are not met. Radcliffe advocates for integrating social-emotional learning (SEL) and metacognitive strategies into gifted education to support students' mental health. She offers practical tips for educators such as fostering a growth mindset, encouraging reflection, providing emotional support, and promoting realistic goal-setting. The post emphasizes the importance of balancing academic rigor with emotional wellness so gifted students can thrive holistically.
A young man in a white shirt and tie is giving a thumbs up
By Lalitha Murali May 15, 2025
In this inspiring student-authored post, 8th-grader Benjamin Byers shares how pursuing personal interests through school programs and extracurriculars has fueled his intellectual growth and future career aspirations in engineering. From participating in Future Cities and NASA STEM clubs to conducting science fair research and mastering 3-D printing, Benjamin illustrates how engaging in interest-driven learning builds critical skills like teamwork, communication, and creativity. He advocates for schools to support diverse student interests, noting how such support boosts motivation, academic success, and social belonging. His experiences underscore the power of gifted programming, clubs, and dedicated teachers in helping students find purpose and community.
A man wearing glasses and a plaid shirt is smiling for the camera
By Dal Drummer May 15, 2025
In this creative and reflective piece, Dal Drummer makes a compelling case for embracing doodling and artistic expression as valid and powerful learning tools. Drawing on personal experience as a lifelong doodler and art educator, Drummer explains how visual and artistic engagement can enhance memory, understanding, and student participation – especially for those who learn best through nontraditional methods. Supported by recent research and personal anecdotes, the post advocates for integrating the arts across the curriculum and recognizing drawing as a legitimate form of processing and demonstrating knowledge. It encourages educators, parents, and caregivers to model creative learning and to celebrate the cognitive benefits of doodling.
A woman wearing glasses and hoop earrings is smiling for the camera.
By Jackie Drummer May 1, 2025
Jackie Drummer explores the dual nature of perfectionism among gifted children and adults, acknowledging its potential to both hinder and motivate. She emphasizes the importance of reframing perfectionism into a healthy, growth-oriented mindset. Drawing on Dr. Carol Dweck's work on growth mindset and Dr. Kenneth Ginsburg's insights, she offers practical strategies for adults to model resilience, self-compassion, and process-focused learning. The post includes thoughtful discussion questions to guide conversations about perfectionism, success, and emotional well-being.
April 15, 2025
In this post, a concerned parent and educator warns of the profound harm that dismantling the U.S. Department of Education would cause for students, especially those who are low-income, have disabilities, are twice-exceptional, or are gifted. The post outlines the Department's historical mission to ensure equal access and foster educational excellence, and highlights how recent efforts to strip funding and oversight from public schools threaten to destabilize essential support systems. The author calls on educators, parents, and advocates to raise their voices, defend public education, and push back against policies that jeopardize the rights and futures of vulnerable students.
A man is playing a game of chess on a glass table
By Maria Katsaros-Molzahn April 15, 2025
In "Questioning is the Door of Knowledge," Dr. Uzeyir Ogurlu explores the vital role that questioning plays in the learning process, describing it as a powerful indicator of intelligence and a critical component of higher-order thinking. Referencing Bloom's Taxonomy, he explains how formulating thoughtful questions requires deep understanding and analytical thinking. In an age where technology can provide instant answers, Dr. Ogurlu urges educators and adults to encourage students to ask meaningful questions – emphasizing that the act of questioning fosters curiosity, reflection, and deeper learning. He also highlights how modeling this behavior can empower students to embrace learning and overcome the fear of "not knowing."
Show More